Milburn Review: Creating opportunities for young people must not come at the expense of developing the existing workforce

Nov 18 2026

Mike Worley, Managing Director, The Opportunity Provider

Alan Milburn’s review is a welcome contribution to one of the biggest challenges facing the country. We absolutely support the ambition to double the number of young people completing apprenticeships over the next decade. It is something we have been calling for ourselves, and employers must be at the heart of making it happen. But while the ambition is right, we need to be careful that some of the proposed changes don’t actually make it harder for businesses to recruit, develop and retain young people.

My biggest concern is the proposal to reduce apprenticeship funding for those aged 25 and over.

I fully understand the need to prioritise young people, but we shouldn’t be creating a situation where investing in one generation comes at the expense of another.

Across Hospitality, Retail, Adult Care and Early Years, we see every day how developing existing employees creates opportunities for others. When someone progresses into a supervisory role, or a supervisor moves into management, that often creates a vacancy for someone taking their first step into work.

It is also worth remembering that young people entering employment for the first time need good managers around them. People who can coach, support, encourage and help them through those early challenges of working life.

If we are serious about tackling youth unemployment, it cannot just be about getting more young people through the door. We have to make sure they stay, develop and see a future with their employer.

That is why continuing to invest in workforce development is so important.

Employers are already paying into the Apprenticeship Levy, yet their ability to use that funding to develop their people has become increasingly restricted. We have heard plenty about greater flexibility, but we have yet to see enough of it in practice.

Asking businesses to contribute more towards developing experienced employees could discourage investment, restrict progression and ultimately reduce the opportunities available to younger recruits.

There is also a wider consideration. Training providers need a sustainable business model if they are going to deliver the growth in youth apprenticeships that we all want to see. Reducing investment in adult apprenticeships risks weakening that capacity at precisely the time we need to be strengthening it.

There is, however, much in the review that we welcome.

The proposal to remove the Treasury’s top slice of the Apprenticeship Levy and reinvest that money into apprenticeships is a positive step.

We also welcome the proposed increases in employer incentives and the introduction of a £2,000 incentive for training providers. This recognises the important role providers play, not just in delivering training, but in working with employers to create opportunities and supporting young people through to completion.

I would like to see that thinking go a little further.

For many smaller businesses, the challenge isn’t simply the cost of recruiting someone. It is finding the time and resources to train them properly, provide cover while they are learning and develop the managers responsible for supporting them.

That is why we have been advocating the principles of a First Job Training Credit, helping employers meet some of those practical costs.

Getting a young person into work is the first step. Giving them the right support to succeed is what makes the difference.

I am also pleased to see recognition of Hospitality and Retail through the proposed phased reduction in employer National Insurance costs for 21 to 24-year-olds, when finances allow.

These are two of the country’;s biggest career starter sectors. They employ young people in communities across the UK and offer genuine opportunities to build long-term careers.

Adult Care and Early Years have an equally important role to play, providing rewarding careers and essential services within those same communities. But these sectors also rely heavily on experienced, well-trained people, which reinforces why we must protect opportunities for workforce development.

One area where I would encourage the Government to think again is the proposal for another separate pre-apprenticeship programme.

Of course, some young people need additional preparation and support before entering employment, and there will be occupations where that is essential.

But many employers, particularly in Hospitality and Retail, already recruit people with no previous experience. They are ready and willing to give young people their first opportunity.

Rather than creating another stage between a young person and a job, why not work more closely with those employers and the training providers who already have those relationships?

Independent training providers have the experience, reach and employer connections to make a real difference here. We should be building on that rather than introducing unnecessary complexity.

We also believe Foundation Apprenticeships have an important part to play, but they need greater flexibility. Young people should be able to progress into a full Level 2 or Level 3 apprenticeship as soon as they and their employer are ready, while retaining up to eight months of support for those who need it.

Through our First Job. Future Career. campaign, we have been making the case for Hospitality, Retail, Adult Care and Early Years to be recognised for the vital role they can play in addressing youth unemployment.

These sectors already provide thousands of young people with their first experience of work, often without the barriers to entry found elsewhere. They have the employers, the opportunities and the career pathways. We need government policy to help them do more.

Ultimately, success shouldn’t just be measured by how many young people start an apprenticeship or get their first job. It should be measured by how many stay in employment, develop their skills, progress and build successful careers.

We shouldn’t be making youth employment and adult workforce development compete against each other. The two go hand in hand.

If we want more young people to have a first chance, we must also invest in the people, businesses and training providers who will help make that first chance a good one.

Of course, these are recommendations, not Government policy. Before making any final decisions, Government must listen carefully to the employers who will ultimately be responsible for creating these opportunities.

They hold the key to tackling youth unemployment, and their experience, challenges and willingness to invest in the next generation must be at the heart of any reforms.

  • First Job. Future Career.’ campaign challenges Adult Social Care businesses to ‘Commit to Youth’ and create meaningful opportunities for the next generation.

  • National campaign ‘First Job. Future Career’, encourages Funeral Service Employers to ‘Commit to Youth’ and create meaningful career opportunities through training, apprenticeships and professional development.

  • Early Years Education employers urged to ‘Commit to Youth’ and develop the next generation of childcare professionals